The Library of Alexandria: What Was Actually Lost?

The Library of Alexandria: What Was Actually Lost?

According to the physician Galen, writing in the second century CE, the Ptolemaic king Ptolemy III once asked Athens to lend him the official state copies of the plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides so that his scribes could copy them. Athens demanded a deposit of fifteen talents of silver, a huge sum. The king paid it, had the copies made, kept the originals for his library in Alexandria, and sent the copies back to Athens, letting the deposit go. Whether or not the story is true in every detail, it says a great deal about the institution he was building: a library that aimed to hold every book worth having.

A colonnaded hall lined with shelves of papyrus scrolls, Alexandria's harbour visible through an archway

Illustration: the Library of Alexandria as it might have looked; no reliable picture of it survives.

The Mouseion and its library

The library was founded in Alexandria, probably under Ptolemy I or his son Ptolemy II in the early third century BCE, as part of the Mouseion, the "shrine of the Muses", from which the word museum comes. It was less a reading room than a state-funded research institute. Scholars lived there on royal salaries, with free meals and lodging, and worked on poetry, medicine, mathematics, astronomy and geography. The geographer Strabo, who visited around 20 BCE, describes the Mouseion as part of the palace quarter, with a covered walk, an arcade and a large hall where the scholars ate together.

The Ptolemies collected aggressively. Galen also records that books found on ships arriving in Alexandria were taken to be copied, and the copies returned to their owners, with the originals labelled "from the ships". How many scrolls the library held is unknown. Ancient figures range from about 40,000 to 700,000, and modern historians, among them Roger Bagnall in an influential 2002 article, treat the larger numbers with deep suspicion. No count from the time survives. The poet and scholar Callimachus compiled the Pinakes, a catalogue of Greek literature in 120 books, which suggests a collection of very large size by ancient standards.

Who worked there

The mathematician Euclid taught in Alexandria around 300 BCE and wrote the Elements there or nearby. Eratosthenes, who became head of the library around 245 BCE, compared the angle of the noon sun at Alexandria and at Syene, modern Aswan, and used the distance between them to estimate the circumference of the Earth, with a result probably within a few per cent of the true figure. The physicians Herophilus and Erasistratus carried out some of the first systematic dissections of the human body. The library's heads also included scholars of Homer, notably Aristophanes of Byzantium and Aristarchus of Samothrace, whose work fixing the text of the Iliad and Odyssey underlies the editions read today.

How it was lost

There was no single night on which the library burned. Its decline took centuries, and the famous destructions were several separate events that later writers often merged into one.

The first blow was political. In 145 BCE Ptolemy VIII, at war with his own family, purged the Greek intellectuals of Alexandria; Aristarchus fled to Cyprus, and the library never regained its earlier standing as the centre of Greek scholarship.

In 48 BCE Julius Caesar, besieged in Alexandria during the civil war, set fire to ships in the harbour, and the fire spread. Plutarch, writing about 150 years later, says it destroyed "the great library". The philosopher Seneca, writing closer to the event, says 40,000 scrolls were burned, and the historian Cassius Dio says warehouses near the docks holding grain and books were lost. Most historians now think the fire destroyed books stored near the harbour, perhaps a large part of the collection, but not the Mouseion itself, which Strabo saw in use a generation later.

Under Roman rule the Mouseion continued, but with less money and less prestige. In 272 CE, during the war between the emperor Aurelian and the forces of Zenobia of Palmyra, the palace quarter where it stood was largely destroyed, according to the fourth-century historian Ammianus Marcellinus. A "daughter library" survived at the Serapeum, a temple of the god Serapis in another part of the city, until 391 CE, when Christians led by the bishop Theophilus destroyed the temple after the emperor Theodosius banned pagan worship.

A later story claims that after the Arab conquest of Egypt in 642 the caliph Umar ordered the remaining books burned, saying that if they agreed with the Qur'an they were unnecessary and if they disagreed they were harmful. It first appears in writers of the late twelfth and thirteenth centuries, more than 500 years after the event, and no earlier Christian or Muslim source mentions it. Historians widely regard it as a fiction, and by 642 there was probably no great library left to burn.

What was lost

A papyrus fragment of Euclid's Elements found at Oxyrhynchus

Many works the library held survive only as fragments quoted by later writers. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain

We cannot list what disappeared, which is itself the loss. Sophocles is said to have written 123 plays, and only seven survive complete; Aeschylus wrote some 70 to 90, of which seven survive. Whole works of history, science and poetry are known only from their titles or from quotations in later authors. Some losses happened in Alexandria, but many happened elsewhere and later, as papyrus rolls rotted and were not copied onto the more durable parchment books that replaced them from the fourth century CE.

The works that survived were mostly those copied many times and kept in many places, in Constantinople, in monasteries, and in Baghdad, where scholars of the Abbasid period translated Greek science and philosophy into Arabic and preserved works that would otherwise be lost. Our articles on how paper remade the Abbasid world and on Taxila look at two other ancient centres of learning. In Alexandria, a new library, the Bibliotheca Alexandrina, opened in 2002 close to where the old palace quarter is thought to have stood. It is a commemoration, not a continuation: none of the ancient collection survives.

Sources

  1. Plutarch, Life of Caesar 49 (the fire of 48 BCE), translated by Bernadotte Perrin, LacusCurtius. https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Plutarch/Lives/Caesar*.html
  2. Ammianus Marcellinus, History 22.16.12–15 (Alexandria, the Brucheion and the Serapeum), translated by J. C. Rolfe, Loeb Classical Library.
  3. Roger S. Bagnall, "Alexandria: library of dreams", Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 146 (2002): 348–362.
  4. World History Encyclopedia, "Library of Alexandria". https://www.worldhistory.org/Library_of_Alexandria/
  5. Bibliotheca Alexandrina. https://www.bibalex.org/en/default

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.