The Vanishing Imam: Inside Islam's Greatest Unsolved Theological Mystery
In 260 AH (874 CE), the eleventh Imam of the Twelver Shia, Hasan al-Askari, died in Samarra, the Abbasid capital on the Tigris, at the age of about twenty-eight. According to the account preserved by the tenth-century scholar Ibn Babawayh, known as Shaykh al-Saduq, his brother Ja'far stepped forward to lead the funeral prayer, and a small boy came out of the house, pulled at his cloak, and said, "Step back, uncle. I have more right to pray over my father than you." The boy led the prayer. Twelver Shia believe he was Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, then about five years old, and that after that day he was kept hidden by God's will. They believe he is alive today and will return as al-Mahdi, the rightly guided one, to fill the earth with justice.
The doctrine of his concealment, the ghayba or occultation, has shaped Shia Islam for more than eleven centuries. It is also a question historians cannot settle with the usual tools, because it turns on a person whom, by the tradition's own account, almost no one was allowed to see.

Illustration: the al-Askari shrine in Samarra, Iraq.
Samarra under watch
The tenth and eleventh Imams, Ali al-Hadi and Hasan al-Askari, spent most of their lives in Samarra under the eye of the Abbasid caliphs, who had moved them there from Medina and treated their following as a political threat. The name al-Askari, "of the garrison", comes from the military quarter of the city where they lived. Shia sources say the birth of al-Askari's son, in 255 AH (869 CE), was kept secret for his safety. When al-Askari died, the authorities searched his house and had his household watched to find out whether he had left an heir.
What followed was a period the Shia themselves called the hayra, the time of perplexity. The scholar al-Hasan ibn Musa al-Nawbakhti, writing a few decades later, counted around fourteen groups among al-Askari's followers. Some said he had no son; some followed his brother Ja'far, whom the Twelvers later called al-Kadhdhab, the liar, for denying his nephew; some believed al-Askari himself would return. The view that eventually prevailed, and became Twelver Shi'ism, was that he had a son who was alive and in hiding.
Historians outside the tradition note that the boy's birth is recorded only in Shia sources, mostly written down in the century after. That does not settle the question one way or the other. It means the belief rests, as the tradition itself says, on the testimony of trusted companions and the chains of narration they passed on.
Four deputies
For about seventy years, the Twelver community did not lose contact. According to its sources, the hidden Imam communicated through four successive deputies, the nuwwab, who carried written replies, known as tawqi'at, to questions on law and doctrine, and received the religious dues that believers sent. This was the Minor Occultation, al-ghayba al-sughra.
The first deputy, Uthman ibn Sa'id al-Amri, had already acted as agent for the tenth and eleventh Imams. After his death his son, Muhammad ibn Uthman al-Amri, served for about forty years until 305 AH (917 CE). The third, al-Husayn ibn Ruh al-Nawbakhti, from a prominent Baghdad family with connections at the Abbasid court, served until his death in 326 AH (938 CE). The fourth, Ali ibn Muhammad al-Samarri, served for only three years. The system made it possible for a persecuted community to keep a single line of authority, and the deputies spent much effort exposing false claimants who tried to set themselves up as rival "gates" to the Imam.
The Minor Occultation ended with a letter. Shia sources report that a few days before al-Samarri's death in 329 AH (941 CE), he showed his companions a final message from the Imam: al-Samarri would die in six days; he should appoint no successor; the "complete occultation" had begun, and anyone claiming to have seen the Imam before certain signs appeared should be treated as a liar. He died on the day foretold, and no one has held the office since. Twelver Shia regard the period since then, the Major Occultation or al-ghayba al-kubra, as still continuing.
How the doctrine was defended
In the century after 941, Twelver scholars set out to explain and defend the occultation, partly against Sunni and Zaydi critics who asked how a hidden Imam could guide anyone. Muhammad ibn Ibrahim al-Nu'mani compiled his Kitab al-Ghayba around 342 AH (953 CE), gathering hadith from earlier Imams that, he argued, had foretold a long absence. Shaykh al-Saduq wrote Kamal al-Din wa Tamam al-Ni'ma, which preserves most of the stories of the boy's birth and the deputies. Shaykh al-Tusi's Kitab al-Ghayba, finished in 447 AH (1055 CE), set out the theological argument: God would not leave the world without a proof, a hujja, but the Imam could remain hidden while the dangers to him remained. A comparison found in the hadith puts it this way: people benefit from the hidden Imam as they benefit from the sun when it is behind a cloud.
Sunni Muslims also expect a Mahdi near the end of time, drawing on hadith in collections such as those of Abu Dawud and al-Tirmidhi. Most Sunni scholars, though, hold that he has not yet been born, and will be a descendant of the Prophet named Muhammad, without identifying him with al-Askari's son.
A belief with consequences
The occultation changed how authority worked in Shia Islam. With no Imam present to give rulings, responsibility passed gradually to the learned. Over the following centuries, Twelver jurists, the mujtahids, came to be seen as the Imam's general deputies, a development that eventually produced the system of senior religious authorities, the marja'iyya, that guides Shia communities from Najaf and Qom today. The modern Iranian doctrine of wilayat al-faqih, the guardianship of the jurist, is one later and much-debated extension of the same idea.
The expectation of the Mahdi has also produced claimants. In 1844 the Iranian merchant Sayyid Ali Muhammad declared himself the Bab, the "gate" to the hidden Imam, starting the movement from which the Baha'i faith later grew. In 1881 Muhammad Ahmad in Sudan proclaimed himself the Mahdi and led a revolt against Egyptian rule. In November 1979 armed men led by Juhayman al-Otaybi seized the Grand Mosque in Mecca in the name of a Mahdi of their own choosing. None of these was accepted by mainstream Shia or Sunni scholarship.
In Samarra, the shrine of the tenth and eleventh Imams, al-Askari mosque, stands over their graves, and beside it is the cellar, the sardab, associated with the hidden Imam. Its golden dome was destroyed by bombs in February 2006, an attack that set off some of the worst sectarian violence of the Iraq war, and has since been rebuilt. Pilgrims still come to it, and in Shia communities around the world the fifteenth of Sha'ban, the date tradition gives for the Imam's birth, is still celebrated.
Sources
- Jassim M. Hussain, The Occultation of the Twelfth Imam: A Historical Background (London, 1982), Al-Islam.org. https://www.al-islam.org/occultation-twelfth-imam-historical-background-jassim-m-hussain
- Encyclopaedia Iranica, "Ḡayba" (occultation). https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/gayba
- Encyclopaedia Iranica, "ʿAskarī, Abū Moḥammad Ḥasan". https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/askari-abu-mohammad-hasan-b
- Encyclopaedia Iranica, "Nawbaḵti family" (al-Husayn ibn Ruh and al-Hasan ibn Musa al-Nawbakhti). https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/nawbakti-family
- Encyclopaedia Iranica, "Mahdi". https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/mahdi
Comments (0)
Leave a Reply
Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.
Log in to post a comment.