The Bronze Age Collapse: How Five Empires Fell in a Single Century

The Bronze Age Collapse: How Five Empires Fell in a Single Century

Around 1200 BCE the eastern Mediterranean held the most connected group of states the world had yet seen. The pharaohs of Egypt wrote to the kings of the Hittites, Babylon and Assyria as "brother". A single ship that sank off Uluburun on the southern coast of Turkey around 1300 BCE was carrying ten tonnes of copper from Cyprus, a tonne of tin from much further east, glass ingots, ebony, ivory, and jewellery from half a dozen cultures. Mycenaean palaces in Greece kept accounts in the Linear B script and traded pottery across the sea.

Within about fifty years, most of that world had gone. The Hittite empire broke up. The Mycenaean palaces were destroyed and their writing forgotten. The great trading port of Ugarit on the Syrian coast was burned and never reoccupied. Egypt survived, but lost its empire in the Levant. Historians call this the Late Bronze Age collapse.

A burning coastal city with ships on the horizon

Illustration: a Late Bronze Age coastal city falling, around 1200 BCE.

A system, not a scatter of kingdoms

The interconnection is the key to the collapse. Bronze is copper alloyed with about a tenth as much tin. Copper was fairly common, Cyprus being a major source, but tin was rare. Analysis of tin ingots from the period points to sources as far away as Central Asia and Cornwall, traded through chains of intermediaries. Armies depended on bronze, and kings depended on the gifts, marriages and trade that came with diplomacy. The Amarna letters, some 380 clay tablets found in Egypt in 1887, record that diplomacy in detail: requests for gold, gifts of horses and chariots, arguments over the size of a dowry.

A system like that has strengths and a weakness. Each state was richer for the connections, but a shock in one part could spread to the others.

What happened, place by place

At Ugarit, the archives found in the ruins include some of the most vivid documents of the period. In one letter the king of Ugarit, Ammurapi, writes to the king of Alashiya, on Cyprus, that enemy ships have come, his cities have been burned, and his own troops and ships are away, apparently fighting for the Hittites. Whether it was ever sent is not known. Ugarit was destroyed around 1185 BCE and its site was abandoned.

The Hittite capital, Hattusa, in central Anatolia, was not simply sacked. Excavations by the German archaeologist Jürgen Seeher and others suggest the royal court and administration left over a period of years, taking valuables and records with them, and that the burning came after the city had largely been abandoned. The empire's name survived in a way: smaller "Neo-Hittite" kingdoms in southern Turkey and northern Syria continued for centuries, and the Hebrew Bible's "Hittites" probably refers to them. The original capital, though, was forgotten until a French traveller, Charles Texier, came across its ruins in 1834.

In Greece, the palace centres of Pylos, Mycenae, Tiryns and Thebes were destroyed or abandoned within a few decades of each other. With the palaces went Linear B and the record-keeping it served. The population fell, and for about four centuries Greeks did not write at all.

A drawing of the Medinet Habu relief of Ramesses III's sea battle with the Sea Peoples

Ramesses III recorded his battle with the Sea Peoples at Medinet Habu; drought and failing trade probably played their part too. Image: Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Egypt fought off two waves of attacks by groups its records call the Peoples of the Sea, once under the pharaoh Merneptah around 1208 BCE and again under Ramesses III, whose reliefs at Medinet Habu in Thebes show a land battle and a great sea battle in the eighth year of his reign, about 1177 BCE. Ramesses claimed victory, but Egypt was exhausted, and his reign also saw the first recorded labour strike in history, by tomb-builders at Deir el-Medina who had not been paid their grain rations.

Why it happened

For a long time the Sea Peoples took most of the blame. The Egyptian records name groups such as the Peleset, probably the later Philistines, the Shekelesh and the Sherden. Most historians now see them less as the cause than as a symptom: people displaced from their homes by a crisis already under way, some raiders, some migrants looking for land.

The evidence for drought has grown stronger. In 2013 David Kaniewski and colleagues used pollen from coastal Syria and Cyprus to show a dry period lasting about three centuries, starting around 1200 BCE. In 2023 Sturt Manning and colleagues published tree-ring evidence in Nature from Gordion in central Anatolia showing three consecutive years of severe drought around 1198 to 1196 BCE, exactly when the Hittite state was failing. Hittite letters from the preceding decades already ask Egypt for grain, and Merneptah boasted that he had sent shipments "to keep alive the land of Hatti".

Earthquakes may have added to the damage. In 2000 the geophysicist Amos Nur and the archaeologist Eric Cline argued that many destroyed sites lie on active faults and that a run of large earthquakes over several decades, an "earthquake storm", could explain some of the destruction. Internal unrest, rebellion against palace rule, and the collapse of trade routes were probably part of it too.

The most widely held view today, set out by Cline in his book 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed, is that no single cause was enough on its own. Drought, famine, migration, warfare, earthquakes and disrupted trade hit an interdependent system at the same time, and it failed. Some scholars add a note of caution. The archaeologist Jesse Millek has re-examined many sites listed as destroyed and argues that a good number show little or no evidence of destruction, which suggests the end was patchier and slower in many places than the dramatic picture implies.

What came after

The collapse opened room for new things. With the bronze trade disrupted, ironworking, which did not depend on tin brought from far away, spread across the region. In the Levant, small states filled the gap left by Egypt and the Hittites, among them the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, the Aramaean states and the Phoenician cities. The Phoenicians' simple alphabet of 22 letters, designed for merchants, not palace scribes, was later adopted by the Greeks, and through Greek and Latin became the ancestor of most alphabets used in Europe today, while its Aramaic branch led eventually to the Hebrew and Arabic scripts. When Greeks began to write again in the eighth century BCE, the poems of Homer looked back to a lost age of palaces and heroes that had ended about four hundred years before.

Sources

  1. Sturt W. Manning, Cindy Kocik, Brita Lorentzen and Jed P. Sparks, "Severe multi-year drought coincident with Hittite collapse around 1198–1196 BC", Nature 614 (2023): 719–724. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05693-y
  2. David Kaniewski, Elise Van Campo, Joël Guiot et al., "Environmental roots of the Late Bronze Age crisis", PLOS ONE 8 (2013): e71004. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0071004
  3. Amos Nur and Eric H. Cline, "Poseidon's horses: plate tectonics and earthquake storms in the Late Bronze Age Aegean and eastern Mediterranean", Journal of Archaeological Science 27 (2000): 43–63. https://doi.org/10.1006/jasc.1999.0431
  4. Eric H. Cline, 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed, revised edition (Princeton University Press, 2021).
  5. "Hattusa", Wikipedia (on the gradual abandonment of the capital, citing Seeher and Beckman). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hattusa
  6. "Late Bronze Age collapse", Wikipedia (overview of the evidence, including Millek's re-examination of destruction layers). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Bronze_Age_collapse

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.