Iram of the Pillars: The Lost City Buried Beneath the Sands of Arabia
The Rub' al-Khali, the Empty Quarter of southern Arabia, is the largest continuous expanse of sand in the world, about 650,000 square kilometres of dunes, in places hundreds of kilometres without a well or a village. For most of recorded history it was a blank on the map. It also has a story attached to it: that somewhere beneath the sand lies a city that was swallowed whole, towers, gardens, pillars and all. The Qur'an names it, medieval scholars argued about it, explorers went looking for it, and in 1992 a team using satellite images announced that they had found it. That claim has been debated ever since.

Illustration: the legend of a city of pillars lost under the sands.
What the Qur'an says
The account is short. In Surah al-Fajr (89:6–8) the reader is asked to consider what God did with 'Ad, with Iram dhat al-'imad, "Iram of the pillars", whose like had never been created in the lands. Other passages fill in the picture. The people of 'Ad lived in al-Ahqaf, the curving sand dunes (46:21), and were warned by the prophet Hud. They were strong and proud, built monuments on high places, and were sure no one could overpower them. Their end came as a furious, bitterly cold wind that blew for seven nights and eight days, leaving them like hollow trunks of palm trees (69:6–7).
Two details matter for anyone searching for the place. Al-Ahqaf points to the sand country of southern Arabia, where Oman, Yemen and Saudi Arabia meet. And the destruction is by wind and sand, not earthquake or flood, which is exactly how a desert can bury a settlement without knocking it down.
What medieval scholars made of it
Muslim scholars did not agree. The geographer Yaqut al-Hamawi, in his thirteenth-century dictionary of places, the Mu'jam al-Buldan, collected the different readings: some took Iram as the name of a city, some as a tribe or an ancestor, and some understood the "pillars" as tent poles, describing a people who lived in great tents, not stone buildings. Historians such as al-Tabari and Ibn Kathir preserved the story of 'Ad and Hud from earlier narrators.
Attached to it was the tale of Abdullah ibn Qilaba, a man of the early Islamic period who was said to have gone looking for a lost camel, come upon an empty city of gold and silver with pillars set with jewels, and never found it again. A version of the story reached the Thousand and One Nights. The fourteenth-century historian Ibn Khaldun dismissed it in the introduction to his history, the Muqaddimah, as the kind of tale that survives by repetition, not evidence, pointing out that a city on that scale could not vanish so completely from geography and memory. By the time European explorers arrived, the tradition already contained both the legend and its rebuttal.
"The Atlantis of the sands"
The phrase is usually credited to T. E. Lawrence, who never looked for the place himself. Others did. The British official Bertram Thomas, who made the first recorded crossing of the Empty Quarter by a European in 1930 to 1931, reported that his Bedouin guides showed him old tracks running into the dunes and said they led to Ubar, a rich city destroyed long ago. Wilfred Thesiger crossed the same desert in the 1940s and wrote Arabian Sands, still the classic book about it, but found no city. Two names now circled the same rumour: Iram, from scripture, and Ubar, from the tribes on the desert's edge. Whether they refer to the same place is unknown.
The satellites
In the 1980s an American documentary maker, Nicholas Clapp, became convinced that the old caravan tracks could be traced from space. With the explorer Ranulph Fiennes, the lawyer George Hedges and the archaeologist Juris Zarins, a specialist in Arabian prehistory, he used Landsat and French SPOT satellite images and radar images taken from the space shuttle, which can pick up features under dry sand. They followed faint lines converging on Shisr, in the Dhofar region of Oman, where there was a small ruin and a well that had been used for as long as anyone remembered.
Excavating there in the early 1990s, they found a walled enclosure with towers at the corners, built over a limestone cave. Finds showed the site had been used over a very long time as a watering station on the frankincense route. The cave beneath had collapsed, and part of the fort had fallen into the sinkhole. In February 1992 the discovery was announced to the world's press as Ubar, the lost city of the sands. Shisr is now part of the UNESCO World Heritage Site "Land of Frankincense", together with the frankincense trees of Wadi Dawkah and the ports of Khor Rori and al-Baleed.
Why the question is still open
The excitement outran the evidence, and the archaeologists, Zarins among them, said so. Shisr is an important caravan station, but its fort measures tens of metres across. It has no colonnaded streets, no great pillars and no walls enclosing a city.

The fort at Shisr fell into a sinkhole, ordinary geology rather than a divine wind. Photo: 9591353082 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5
Zarins's own view is that "Ubar" was most likely the name of a region or a people, the frankincense-trading network of the interior, of which Shisr was one stop. He has pointed out that the second-century geographer Ptolemy lists a people in southern Arabia whose name has been read as Iobaritae. The collapse, too, is ordinary geology: limestone caves give way, especially when groundwater is drawn down. And nothing found at Shisr bears the name Iram or 'Ad. The name Iram does appear in Nabataean and early Arabic inscriptions at Wadi Rum in southern Jordan, more than a thousand kilometres to the north, which shows it was a real place name, though in a different landscape. A once-popular claim that "Iram" appears on third-millennium tablets from Ebla in Syria has been abandoned by specialists.
What the evidence does show
Southern Arabia in antiquity was not empty. It was the source of frankincense and myrrh, among the most valuable goods of the ancient world, carried north by camel to Egypt, the Levant and Rome. That trade supported real towns and real wealth, and it depended on desert stations with water, places exactly like Shisr. When demand fell and sea routes replaced the overland tracks, the stations were abandoned and the sand slowly covered them. A prosperous culture fading into the dunes is documented history. Whether one particular buried place is the one the Qur'an names, the evidence cannot say. Only a small part of the Empty Quarter has ever been surveyed by archaeologists.
Sources
- The Qur'an, Surah al-Fajr 89:6–8, Surah al-Ahqaf 46:21 and Surah al-Haqqah 69:6–7, Quran.com. https://quran.com/89/6-8, https://quran.com/46/21, https://quran.com/69/6-7
- Ibn Khaldun, The Muqaddimah, translated by Franz Rosenthal, Muslim Philosophy online edition. https://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ik/Muqaddimah/
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre, "Land of Frankincense". https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1010
- "Iram of the Pillars", Wikipedia (the Shisr excavation and the scholarly debate, with references). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iram_of_the_Pillars
- Nicholas Clapp, The Road to Ubar: Finding the Atlantis of the Sands (Houghton Mifflin, 1998); Bertram Thomas, Arabia Felix (1932); Wilfred Thesiger, Arabian Sands (1959).
Comments (0)
Leave a Reply
Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.
Log in to post a comment.