How Siraj-ud-Daula Lost the Battle of Plassey

How Siraj-ud-Daula Lost the Battle of Plassey

On the morning of 23 June 1757, in a mango grove beside the village of Palashi, anglicised as Plassey, on the Bhagirathi river, the Nawab of Bengal, Siraj-ud-Daula, faced a British East India Company force a fraction the size of his own. By evening his army had scattered, and within ten days he was dead, killed on the orders of the son of the man who replaced him. Very little fighting decided the day. The outcome had been arranged in the months before, by the Company working with Siraj's own commanders, courtiers and bankers.

A Bengal river and mango groves in monsoon light, an old lodge in the distance

Illustration: the mango groves and river near Plassey in Bengal.

A difficult inheritance

Siraj-ud-Daula became Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa in April 1756, on the death of his grandfather Alivardi Khan. He was in his early twenties and inherited a court full of people who had hoped for someone else. His aunt Ghaseti Begum had backed a rival; senior commanders distrusted him; and the great banking house of the Jagat Seths, whose credit underpinned the whole economy of Bengal, found him difficult. Siraj moved fast and harshly. He seized Ghaseti Begum's wealth and treated the Jagat Seths with contempt. In eighteenth-century Bengal the Seths were kingmakers as much as bankers, and offending them handed the Company a powerful ally.

He was also alarmed by the Company's new fortifications at Fort William in Calcutta, built, it said, against the French, but which Siraj rightly suspected were meant to make the Company independent of him. When the Company refused to stop, he marched on Calcutta in June 1756 and took it. The deaths of British prisoners held overnight in a small guardroom, the "Black Hole of Calcutta", followed. The numbers given by the survivor John Zephaniah Holwell, 123 dead out of 146, have long been doubted as exaggerated, but the story became powerful propaganda. From Madras, Robert Clive and Admiral Charles Watson sailed with a force to retake the city.

An 18th-century print of Fort William and ships on the Hooghly at Calcutta

Calcutta, which Clive recaptured in January 1757. Image: Rijksmuseum / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

The conspiracy

Clive retook Calcutta in January 1757 and in March captured the French settlement at Chandannagar, which alarmed Siraj further. The decisive campaign was political. Through William Watts, the Company's agent at the Nawab's court in Murshidabad, Clive opened secret talks with a faction ready to remove him.

At its centre was Mir Jafar, Siraj's paymaster-general and commander of a large part of the army, who was promised the throne if he stood aside in any battle with the Company. The Jagat Seths helped broker the deal and gave it financial backing. A treaty promised huge payments to the Company and its officers. When Omichand, a Calcutta merchant who acted as a go-between, threatened to reveal the plot unless he received a large commission, Clive had two versions of the treaty drawn up: a real one, and a fake one on red paper that included Omichand's payment. Admiral Watson refused to sign the fake, and Clive had his signature added without his consent. Other commanders, among them Yar Latif Khan and Rai Durlabh, were also brought into the understanding that they would not fight for Siraj.

The battlefield

On paper the battle should not have been close. Siraj had around 50,000 men, with a large body of cavalry, war elephants, and artillery, part of it served by French gunners under a Monsieur Sinfray who had escaped from Chandannagar. Clive had about 3,000, of whom fewer than a thousand were European soldiers and the rest Indian sepoys, with a handful of field guns. Clive later admitted that he held a council of war the evening before and came close to turning back. He went on because Mir Jafar had assured him that most of the Nawab's army would not fight.

The battle opened with an exchange of artillery. Around midday a heavy monsoon shower swept the field. The Company's troops had covered their powder; most of Siraj's gunners had not, and much of their powder was soaked. When the Nawab's cavalry advanced, assuming the British guns were silenced too, they ran into heavy fire.

The turning point was the death of Mir Madan, one of the few commanders who was fighting loyally, killed by a cannonball in the early afternoon. His death threw the loyal part of the army into confusion. Shaken, Siraj sent for Mir Jafar and asked his advice. Mir Jafar told him to pull back for the day. The contingents of Mir Jafar, Yar Latif Khan and Rai Durlabh, the largest part of the army, never engaged. Once the withdrawal began, Clive's troops pressed forward, the retreat turned into a rout, and the Nawab's camp was overrun. The Company lost about 22 men killed and some 50 wounded.

Flight and death

Siraj escaped from the field and fled to Murshidabad, then tried to reach Patna, hoping to join French forces in the north. He was recognised and captured near Rajmahal, brought back to Murshidabad, and killed on the night of 2 to 3 July by Muhammadi Beg, on the orders of Mir Jafar's son Miran.

Mir Jafar became Nawab, as promised, but as the Company's client. The payments he had agreed to, to the Company and its officers, with Clive among the largest personal beneficiaries, drained Bengal's treasury. When he could not pay, the Company replaced him in 1760 with his son-in-law, Mir Qasim, and when Mir Qasim resisted, defeated him at Buxar in 1764. In 1765 the Mughal emperor granted the Company the diwani, the right to collect the revenues of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa. Plassey had opened the way to it.

Why he lost

Siraj-ud-Daula lost Plassey through a collapse of political trust, not a lack of soldiers. He had alienated the bankers and nobles whose support any ruler of Bengal needed, and they in turn financed and guaranteed the plot against him. Several of his most senior commanders had been won over before the armies met, so the force that marched to Plassey was never as united as its size suggested. And by the time he understood how far the betrayal went, after Mir Madan's death, he had no one else to rely on. The Company exploited each of those weaknesses, through Clive's willingness to negotiate, bribe and forge to secure the result before the first shot.

The main contemporary accounts all have their own interests. Clive's letters and his evidence to a parliamentary inquiry in 1772 defended his conduct. Robert Orme, a Company official, wrote the first full history of the campaign. Ghulam Husain Khan Tabatabai's Persian history Siyar al-Muta'akhkhirin, finished in 1781, was written by a man close to the Bengal court, under the rule of Siraj's successors. Historians read all of them with caution.

Sources

  1. National Army Museum, "Battle of Plassey". https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/battle-plassey
  2. "Battle of Plassey", Wikipedia (with references to Orme, the Siyar al-Muta'akhkhirin and modern studies). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Plassey
  3. William Dalrymple, The Anarchy: The Relentless Rise of the East India Company (Bloomsbury, 2019).
  4. Robert Orme, A History of the Military Transactions of the British Nation in Indostan from the Year 1745, vol. 2 (London, 1778).
  • Tags:
  • No tags

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.